Return to site

Contagion Risks from Coronavirus

· Coronavirus,Health,Healthcare

Contagion Risks from Coronavirus

broken image

Non-invasive ventilation and high-flow nasal cannula are treatments for acute respiratory failure, including in severe cases of viral pneumonia such as COVID-19.

They are reputed to be risky techniques that spread the virus, and are banned in many hospitals for the treatment of COVID-19.

We might ask some questions about this.

Where is the evidence that non-invasive ventilation (NIV) and high-flow nasal cannula therapy (HFNC) spread viral particulates or droplets?

How far does this spread go?

And where on the mask does the spread come from? (Could better masks that don’t cause this spread be designed?)

Here’s a look at some of the literature on the topic.

In a 5-person study of high flow nasal cannula usage, in which the participants gargled with food dye and coughed, with and without wearing a well-fitting HFNC mask, cough-generated droplets spread to a mean (standard deviation) distance of 2.48 (1.03) m at baseline and 2.91 (1.09) m with HFNC.

A maximum cough distance of 4.50 m was reported when using HFNC.

A separate study found that non-cough droplets extended a maximum of 62 cm when using HFNC. High-flow nasal cannula usage does spray cough droplets farther, by 0.42 m on average, than baseline.[1]

While HFNC can spread the virus farther than baseline, and farther than the 2-meter separation that’s the recommended minimum distance between COVID-19 patients in a hospital, it is unlikely to spread droplets from one room to another, for instance, through wall vents.

Non-invasive ventilation has been reported to increase the risk of viral transmission to healthcare workers in the case of SARS, but so did invasive ventilation. Oxygen therapy and NIV can disperse air up to 1M around the patient.[2] Again, this is not enough for virus particles to travel from room to room.

In a study of 628 healthcare workers treating patients with severe SARS, presence in the room during non-invasive ventilation (p < 0.01), intubation (p < 0.01), and manual ventilation before intubation (p = 0.02) were independently associated with increased risk of healthcare workers contracting SARS; in a multivariate model, the only one of these procedures that stayed significant was intubation (OR = 2.79, p = 0.004).

Non-invasive ventilation and manual (bag mask) ventilation may be able to spread disease to healthcare workers, but no more so than intubation.[3]

In an experiment with noninvasive ventilation (BiPAP) with an oronasal face mask, on a dummy with a realistic model of human respiration, marking the air with smoke particles exhaled through the “airway”, smoke was found to leak from the mask through the six small exhaust holes on the nasal bridge of the mask.

The smoke leaked a maximum of 0.45 M away from the dummy.[4]

In a study comparing non-invasive ventilation in normal subjects, subjects with cold symptoms, and subjects with infective exacerbations of chronic lung disease, NIV produced large (>10 um) droplets in the chronic lung disease and cold patients, but did not produce an aerosol.

Due to the large size of droplets, most fall onto surfaces within 1M of the patient.

Again, while healthcare workers are at risk (and need to wear personal protective equipment while treating patients with NIV) it is unlikely that NIV could send particulates into surrounding rooms.[5]

In a study sampling the air around 39 H1N1 influenza patients after various procedures, noninvasive ventilation was not associated with a significantly increased risk of finding H1N1 RNA in the air.[6]

There is room for doubt, given the evidence, whether non-invasive ventilation in fact spreads virus particles to healthcare workers. There is no evidence at all that particulates from non-invasive ventilation masks can spread more than a few meters.

Written by Sarah Constantin

Coronavirus Oxygen Supplementation 101

Coronavirus: The Global Economic Impact

Home Care for Coronavirus

Coronavirus Causes Long Term Problems?

Online Coronavirus Scams Proliferate

What Is The True Coronavirus Case Fatality Rate For Young People?

How Likely Are Young People to be Hospitalized With Coronavirus?

Living On The Edge of A New Society

Coronavirus Will Test the Limits of Our Hospitals

Coronavirus Catapults Global Testing Innovation

Spain Suffers Under Coronavirus

Data, Models & Misinformation on the Coronavirus

Origins of the Coronavirus

Coronavirus Travels the Silk Road

Coronavirus Attacks Italy's Sick and Elderly

Is the New Coronavirus Drug a Cure?

What is the Mystery of Germany's Low Coronavirus Fatality Rate?

Coronavirus & the Economy

The World Will Be More Technologically Advanced After the COVID-19 Pandemic

Why has the Coronavirus Not Exploded in Japan?

Italy's Coronavirus Death Rate is Falling

Conquering The Coronavirus

Coronavirus Speeds Up Robotic Revolution

Economic Depression Will Destroy More Lives Than Coronavirus

Can Hydroxychloroquine be Used to Treat Coronavirus?

Northern Italy & Wuhan: Partners for Better or Worse

The Race for the Coronavirus Cure

How Did Taiwan Manage the Coronavirus so Well?

What is the US Coronavirus Fatality Rate?

Travel Ban Saves Airlines Billions

Coronavirus Superspreader?

Deep Learning Detects Coronavirus

Singapore's Coronavirus Patients Have a 0% Mortality Rate So Far... Why?

AI is Mapping the Coronavirus and Inferring its Possible Economic Impact

Coronavirus: Fact from Fiction

Coronavirus Attacks Italy's Sick and Elderly

Interview with NASA Astronaut Scott Kelly: An American Hero​

13 Questions With General David Petraeus

Why Choose Machine Learning Investing Over A Traditional Financial Advisor?

Interview With Home Depot Co-Founder Ken Langone

Interview with the Inventor of Amazon's Alexa

Automation and the Rebirth of American Retail

China Debuts Stealth Unmanned Combat Aerial Vehicle

Sweden's Economy Embraces AI & Automation

Austria's Automated Ai & Robotic Future Is Now

Nuclear Submarines: A 7,000 Lb Swiss Watch

Ai Can Write Its Own Computer Program

On Black Holes: Gateway to Another Dimension, or Ghosts of Stars’ Pasts?

Egypt's Artificial Intelligence Future

Supersonic Travel: The Future of Aviation

Was Our Moon Once Habitable?

The Modern Global Arms Race

NASA Seeks New Worlds

Cowboy Turned Space Surgeon

Shedding Light on Dark Matter: Using Machine Learning to Unravel Physics’ Hardest Questions

When High-Tech Meets Low-Tech Economy: Ai & the Construction Industry

Aquaponics: How Advanced Technology Grows Vegetables In The Desert

The World Cup Does Not Have a Lasting Positive Impact on Hosting Countries

Artificial Intelligence is Transforming the Forex Market

Do Machines Dream? Inside the Dreams of a Machine

Can Ai Replace Human Ski Coaches?

America’s Next Spy Plane

Faster than Sound and Undetectable by Radar

The Implications of Machine Learning on Condensed Matter Physics & Quantum Computing

Crafting Eco-Sustainability: WTC and Environmental Sustainability

Can Ai Transform Swimming?

Argentina's AI Future: Reversing a Century of Decline

Tennis & Artificial Intelligence

Kazakhstan's Ai Aspirations

Peru's Ai Future Will Drive Economic Growth

The Colombian Approach to the AI Revolution

How AI Can Explain Its Thinking

Singapore: Ai & Robotic City

Ai in New Zealand

Brazil & Artificial Intelligence​

Denmark & Ai

Can Ai Replace Human Ski Coaches?

Tennis & Artificial Intelligence


[1] Loh, Ne-Hooi Will, et al. “The impact of high-flow nasal cannula (HFNC) on coughing distance: implications on its use during the novel coronavirus disease outbreak.” Canadian Journal of Anesthesia/Journal canadien d’anesthésie (2020): 1-2.

[2]Hui, David S. “Severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS): lessons learnt in Hong Kong.” Journal of thoracic disease 5.Suppl 2 (2013): S122.

[3]Raboud, Janet, et al. “Risk factors for SARS transmission from patients requiring intubation: a multicentre investigation in Toronto, Canada.” PLoS One 5.5 (2010).

[4]Hui, David S., et al. “Noninvasive positive-pressure ventilation: an experimental model to assess air and particle dispersion.” Chest 130.3 (2006): 730-740.

[5]Simonds, A. K., et al. “Evaluation of droplet dispersion during non-invasive ventilation, oxygen therapy, nebuliser treatment and chest physiotherapy in clinical practice: implications for management of pandemic influenza and other airborne infections.” Health technology assessment (Winchester, England) 14.46 (2010): 131-172.

[6]Thompson, Katy-Anne, et al. “Influenza aerosols in UK hospitals during the H1N1 (2009) pandemic–the risk of aerosol generation during medical procedures.” PloS one 8.2 (2013).

All Posts

Almost done…

We just sent you an email. Please click the link in the email to confirm your subscription!